Key Factors That Went Wrong for India
1. Cautious Chase + Top-Order Collapse
Chasing a modest 193, India adopted a defensive mindset. The top and middle order faltered early, losing momentum and crumbling under sustained pressure from Stokes and Archer .
2. Turning Point: Pant–Rahul Mix-up
India were poised at around 248/3 in the first innings. A disastrous run-out mix-up between Pant and Rahul triggered a collapse, losing seven wickets for just 139 runs—wiping out a potential 50+ run lead .
3. Lack of Support for Jadeja
Ravindra Jadeja weighed in with a heroic unbeaten 61 in the fourth innings, resisting big odds. But beyond him, only wicketkeepers Bumrah and Siraj offered a fight. When India needed a partnership, partners didn’t step up .
4. Disciplined England Bowling
England’s attack applied relentless pressure in the fourth innings. Stokes (3/48) and Archer (3/55) relentlessly pegged India back, backed by Shoaib Bashir’s final wicket—even while nursing a finger injury .
5. Self-Inflicted Errors & Extras
India’s shot selection was overly cautious, allowing England to dominate. Add to that an unusually high number of extras conceded—63 in total—and it gave England unnecessary breathing room .
6. DRS & Umpiring Controversies
KL Rahul’s LBW dismissal via DRS left former captain Sunil Gavaskar fuming. He questioned ball-tracking reliability, with umpiring errors like that unsettling India .
7. Slow Over-Rates From Both Sides
The match suffered from slow over-rates, with nearly 22 overs lost over two days. Veteran Michael Vaughan criticized the lack of urgency and ineffective deterrents .
—
Final Moments
India needed 28 runs with one wicket in hand—but Siraj fell to Bashir, and India were bowled out for 170, sealing a narrow 22-run defeat .
—
Takeaway
In low-chase scenarios, India’s lack of aggression and defensive mindset combined with top-order failures cost them. While Jadeja’s grit and the lower order showed character, the team couldn’t string together the partnerships needed. England’s sharper bowling and tactical drive in pressure overs made the difference.
—
What Lies Ahead
That thrilling loss has given England the edge in the five-match series. India must regroup, rethink their approach in fourth innings chases, address shot selection, and tighten their top-order execution for the upcoming Tests at Old Trafford.